The woman suffrage

Book Review Instructions:

Approved Book, Author’s Source and Professional Review (5 points out of 100)

Review Format (25 points out of 100)

1. Cover Page:

Center the underlined title of the book reviewed, the author’s name, Reviewed by: Your Name, the class (History 1302), and the due date.

2. Minimum Length:

Four (4) complete pages of typed text
Use spell-check to correct spelling errors

3. Margins and Font:

One (1) inch margins
Left justify the margin
Font size is 10-12 point
Number pages consecutively excluding the cover page
Header should be in the upper right hand corner with your last name before page number
4. References:

Minimum of three needed for your book review paper: the biographical information on the author, the book being reviewed, one professional review of the book.

5. Works Cited Page:

Found on the last page of the paper
Alphabetized sources
Use the MLA Handbook for this page

6. General Mechanics:

The MLA handbook should be your guide for the form of the paper. Use acceptable grammar, spelling and neatness. Do not use contractions, slang, 1st or 2nd person, incomplete sentences, short choppy or overlong paragraphs or quotes, passive voice or present tense. This paper is a history paper and should be written in the past tense!

7. Content (70 points out of 100):

Creative title – Place at top of first page of text.
Introductory Paragraph – (1/4 page; 5 points) Begin with an introductory paragraph including the subject of the book and the purpose of the author. NOTE: The first time you mention the book in your paper, the full title of the book and the author must be given.
Author’s Purpose – usually revealed in the preface or forward of the book.
Evaluation of Author’s Credentials – (1/2 page, 10 points)
Research the author’s background using Biography and Genealogy Master Index to locate specific sources like Contemporary Authors – use the most recent source.
Report only the author’s qualifications for writing this book – include education, job experience, other books, awards, possible bias, etc. – be sure to cite sources.
Brief Concise Summary – (1/2 page, 10 points)
Critical Analysis of the Book – (2 1/4 pages, 30 points) This is the heart of the review. Break this part of the paper into separate paragraphs analyzing each of the following issues:
Effectiveness of the Author
Goal – What was the author’s goal? Was it to entertain, inform, and/or persuade you?
Purpose – Did he develop his thesis? Give an example. Did he get you to see his subject as he did? Give an example. did the author achieve his purpose?
Style – What audience did the author write for? Was the book interesting or hard to follow? Use a quote to illustrate.
Objectivity – Was the author balanced or biased in their approach to the subject? Give an example.
Sources – Primary vs. Secondary? Be specific, what types, give names of sources used by the author. How well did the author document the book? How detailed was the information? Too much, not enough? Did the sources add or detract from the book? Give examples.
Special Features – Pictures, chapter titles, maps and general organization – How did they add/subtract to the book?
Professional Review
Minimum of 1 review. Use Book Review Digest or the EBSCO online database to locate at least 1 review of your book and cite the specific review using quotes or paraphrasing of the reviewer’s evaluation of your book. DO NOT CITE BOOK REVIEW DIGEST SINCE IT IS NOT A PROFESSIONAL REVIEW.
Indicate your agreement/disagreement with each professional critic. Why?
Personal Subjective Judgment – (1/2 page, 10 points)
Overall Reaction – Did it aid your understanding/appreciation of the topic with which it dealt? If so, how? Did the book influence you in some way? Examples.
Recommendation – Would your recommend this book for future classes or to a friend or enemy? Why?
Works Cited Page – Last page with alphabetized sources.
Below is the author’s information and I attached the professional review (is highlighted color orange).

———- Forwarded message ———-
Date: Thu, Oct 15, 2015 at 12:41 PM
Subject: LitRC Experience for OMNI Resource Center:Judith McArthur

Literature Resource Center
“Judith McArthur.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2015.
Title: Judith McArthur
Publication Information
American Historian ( 1951 – )
Source: Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. From Literature Resource Center.
Document Type: Biography
[Image Omitted: Gale]
Full Text: COPYRIGHT 2015 Gale, Cengage Learning

Table of Contents:
Further Readings About the Author
Personal Information
Writings by the Author

Born August 5, 1951. Education: Kent State University, B.A.; Syracuse University, M.L.S.; University of Houston, Victoria, M.A.; University of Texas at Austin, Ph.D. Addresses: Office: University of Houston, Victoria, 3007 N. Ben Wilson, Victoria, TX 77901. E-mail:

University of Houston, Victoria, adjunct professor, lecturer in history.


(Editor, with Ruthe Winegarten) Citizens at Last: The Woman Suffrage Movement in Texas: Essays, Ellen C. Temple (Austin, TX), 1987.
(Editor, with Orville Vernon Burton) A Gentleman and an Officer: A Military and Social History of James B. Griffin’s Civil War, Oxford University Press (New York, NY), 1996.
Creating the New Woman: The Rise of Southern Women’s Progressive Culture in Texas, 1893-1918, University of Illinois Press (Urbana, IL), 1998.
(With Harold L. Smith) Minnie Fisher Cunningham: A Suffragist’s Life in Politics, Oxford University Press (New York, NY), 2003.
(Editor, with Angela Boswell) Women Shaping the South: Creating and Confronting Change, University of Missouri Press (Columbia, MO), 2006.


Judith N. McArthur is a historian who specializes in the Civil War and Southern history, as well as the suffragist movement and women’s activism. Her particular focus is women’s issues pertaining to all the aforementioned eras and regions. McArthur earned her bachelor’s degree from Kent State University before receiving her M.L.S. at Syracuse University. She next earned her master’s degree from the University of Houston, Victoria and went on to earn a doctorate at the University of Texas at Austin. McArthur soon returned to the University of Houston, Victoria, where she has worked as an adjunct professor and lecturer in history. Her first book, Citizens at Last: The Woman Suffrage Movement in Texas: Essays, which McArthur edited with Ruthe Winegarten, was published in 1987. The volume was followed in 1996 by A Gentleman and an Officer: A Military and Social History of James B. Griffin’s Civil War. The book, which McArthur edited with Orville Vernon Burton, is a collection of letters by James Griffin, a Confederate Civil War soldier who was a wealthy plantation owner. Griffin owned sixty-one slaves and lived in South Carolina, though he served as a Confederate officer in Virginia. The letters, written from April 1861 to February 1865, are largely addressed to Griffin’s wife, and they mainly discuss his war experience. In an afterword to the collection, McArthur and Burton discuss Griffin’s life after 1865, detailing his move to Texas, one of the few Southern states that had not been destroyed during the war.

A Gentleman and an Officer was applauded by critics, many of whom noted its evenhanded tone and the insight it adds to Civil War studies. “The book is well edited and guaranteed to be politically correct,” noted a Contemporary Review contributor. Marli F. Weiner, writing in the Journal of Southern History, stated that the book is both “compelling in content” as well as “a welcome addition to the genre.” She stated: “McArthur and Burton’s editing is exhaustive. They provide biographical details on every individual mentioned in the letters as well as an introduction that sets the context both for Griffin’s life in Edgefield and his military service. A concluding chapter does the same for the family’s years in Texas.”

In her first solo effort, the 1998 publication Creating the New Woman: The Rise of Southern Women’s Progressive Culture in Texas, 1893-1918, McArthur looks at how the progressive movement affected Texas in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. She examines the national progressive movement and its influence in Texas. McArthur also compares and contrasts the similarities and differences between the two. One influential factor McArthur explores is the World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago; another is the growing volunteerism movement amongst women at the time. The effect of race and suffrage on women’s rights is also discussed in the volume.

Written with Harold L. Smith, Minnie Fisher Cunningham: A Suffragist’s Life in Politics was published in 2003. The book is a straightforward biography of suffrage activist Minnie Fisher Cunningham. McArthur and Smith detail the Texan suffragette’s accomplishments: Cunningham first joined a women’s organization locally and then went on to lead the state’s suffrage movement. Her work at this level with fellow activist Carrie Chapman Catt is also explored. After the passage of the Nineteenth Amendment, which granted women the right to vote, Cunningham worked for the Women’s National Democratic League and the League of Women Voters. The authors note that she also ran as a candidate for the governor of Texas and for a seat in the U.S. Senate. Critics found the book to be a well-written and comprehensive biography. According to Library Journal writer Theresa McDevitt, “The book’s main value is its being the only biography of this significant Texan.” Yet, Journal of Southern History contributor Evan Anders found that “McArthur and … Smith have written a well-researched account of the political activism of Minnie Fisher Cunningham from the early twentieth century until her death in 1964.” Anders also remarked that “the strongest element of the book is the analysis of the tactics that Catt and Cunningham used to promote woman suffrage.”

McArthur’s 2006 book, Women Shaping the South: Creating and Confronting Change, edited with Angela Boswell, also looks at women’s rights and activism. The book is a collection of ten essays that were initially presented or composed as part of the Southern Conference on Women’s History. The essays discuss women’s rights from Revolutionary times to the mid-twentieth century. Some topics discussed include the way women have made a stand against racism to more specific events such as Jane Washington’s crusade to declare Mount Vernon a public property. “The essays are well written and engaging. They fill an important gap in the historiography and, as the editors point out, they give voice to a group of women who have so often been silent backdrops to both the national narrative and Southern history,” declared Sarah Eppler Janda in History: Review of New Books.



American Historical Review, December 1, 1999, Rebecca Edwards, review of Creating the New Woman: The Rise of Southern Women’s Progressive Culture in Texas, 1893-1918, p. 1693.
Choice, October 1, 1998, A. Graebner, review of Creating the New Woman, p. 381; September 1, 2004, C.A. Kanes, review of Minnie Fisher Cunningham: A Suffragist’s Life in Politics, p. 175.
Civil War History, September 1, 1999, Steve Jones, review of A Gentleman and an Officer: A Military and Social History of James B. Griffin’s Civil War, p. 260.
Contemporary Review, October 1, 1997, review of A Gentleman and an Officer, p. 222.
History: Review of New Books, January 1, 2007, Sarah Eppler Janda, review of Women Shaping the South: Creating and Confronting Change, p. 57.
Journal of American History, September 1, 2000, LeeAnn Whites, review of Creating the New Woman, p. 676; March 1, 2007, Beverly G. Bond, review of Women Shaping the South, p. 1229.
Journal of American Studies, August 1, 1998, review of A Gentleman and an Officer, p. 295.
Journal of Southern History, February 1, 2000, Gayle Gullett, review of Creating the New Woman, p. 150; February 1, 2001, Marli F. Weiner, review of A Gentleman and an Officer, p. 193; February 1, 2001, review of A Gentleman and an Officer, p. 193; August 1, 2005, Evan Anders, review of Minnie Fisher Cunningham, p. 725; August 1, 2007, Jennifer Ritterhouse, review of Women Shaping the South, p. 760.
Journal of Women’s History, spring, 2000, Pippa Holloway, review of Creating the New Woman, p. 218.
Library Journal, November 15, 2003, Theresa McDevitt, review of Minnie Fisher Cunningham, p. 76.
Southwestern Historical Quarterly, April 1, 2000, R. Blake Dunnavent, review of A Gentleman and an Officer, p. 522; April 1, 2001, Marilyn Dell Brady, review of Creating the New Woman, p. 624; April 1, 2005, Nancy Beck Young, review of Minnie Fisher Cunningham, p. 556; January 1, 2007, Rebecca Montgomery, review of Women Shaping the South, p. 422.
Virginia Magazine of History and Biography, fall, 2006, Ann Denkler, review of Women Shaping the South, p. 519.

H-Net: Humanities and Social Sciences Online, (July 1, 2004), Yvonne Davis Frear, review of Minnie Fisher Cunningham. *

Source Citation (MLA 7th Edition)
“Judith McArthur.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2015.

Gale Document Number: GALE|H1000188256

Copyright and Terms of Use:


Place your order now to enjoy great discounts on this or a similar topic.

People choose us because we provide:

Essays written from scratch, 100% original,

Delivery within deadlines,

Competitive prices and excellent quality,

24/7 customer support,

Priority on their privacy,

Unlimited free revisions upon request, and

Plagiarism free work,


Unlike most other websites we deliver what we promise;

  • Our Support Staff are online 24/7
  • Our Writers are available 24/7
  • Most Urgent order is delivered with 6 Hrs
  • 100% Original Assignment Plagiarism report can be sent to you upon request.

GET 15 % DISCOUNT TODAY use the discount code PAPER15 at the order form.

Type of paper
Academic level
Subject area
Number of pages
Paper urgency
Cost per page: